About Louisville Public Library's Review Crew

The library’s Review Crew offers local teens in grades 6-12 the opportunity to earn community service hours for school or other organizations by reviewing teen books or adult books with teen appeal. We hope to provide local teens with great reading recommendations from their peers while also providing a flexible means of earning volunteer credit.

To join the Crew, please email Teen Services Librarian, Jessica Schwartz, at jschwartz@louisvilleco.gov for more information and review writing guidelines. You will be asked to write a sample review. If your review is accepted, you will be eligible to earn one community service hour for every review submitted. 

Ratings are out of 5 stars:

·         1 star = didn't like it

·         2 stars = it was ok

·         3 stars =  liked it

·         4 stars = really liked it

·         5 stars  = it was amazing

   

Shatter Me by Tahereh Mafi

Book: Shatter me by Tahereh Mafi
Rating: 4 Stars 
Review Writer: Talia C.

Shatter Me by Tahereh Mafi is beloved by many, though I’ve heard some differing opinions, so I wanted to check it out for myself. The novel introduces us to a bleak, decaying world run by the Reestablishment, a totalitarian government that has taken over under the guise of fixing a dying world. At the center of the story is 17-year-old Juliette Ferrars, who has been locked away in a solitary confinement cell for the past year. Juliette carries a terrifying power: her touch is fatal to anyone who comes into contact with her bare skin. Her forced isolation soon ends when a young soldier named Adam enters the picture, getting thrown into the cell alongside Juliette. His appearance triggers a train of events that soon lands her fate into the hands of Warner, the dangerously obsessed commander of Sector 45 who wants to use her as the ultimate weapon of terror. 

The element that stands out the most in this book is Mafi’s unconventional style. Written in a stream-of-consciousness format, the text heavily features metaphors and crossed out sentences.  Before the story starts, In order to avoid confusion, this style choice is explained as being a deliberate one. I believe this choice does an amazing job of demonstrating and conveying Juliette’s fractured psyche after being treated like a monster for so long.

As excellent as the book is, the storyline does present a flaw. Mafi focuses so strongly on the internal thoughts and feelings of Juliette, as well as the building where she is kept prisoner, that the outside world feels vague and undefined. It makes the world feel more like a distant backdrop than a fully recognized dystopian society. The world-building is further expanded on in Unravel Me and Ignite Me, the remaining two books in the trilogy, but the first book including some description of the outside world would help set the scene for the rest.

Overall, Shatter Me is a unique and compelling dystopian novel that stands out through deep character development. Tahereh Mafi uses creative, stylistic writing choices to place the reader inside of her mind. The book delivers a powerful and emotional story of survival that explains why the book boasts this level of popularity. Similar novels include The Darkest Minds by Alexandra Bracken, and Powerless by Lauren Roberts, which I would highly recommend checking out if you enjoy the Shatter Me trilogy.

 

Powerless by Lauren Roberts

Book: Powerless by Lauren Roberts
Rating: 4 Stars 
Review Writer: Talia C.

Powerless by Lauren Roberts has long dominated my social media feed, and I can honestly say that it lives up to the hype, and more. The story unfolds in the ruthless kingdom of Ilya, where a historic plague left survivors with unique magical abilities, elevating them to a ruling class known as the Elites. Meanwhile, the un-gifted “Ordinaries”, as they are referred to by the Elites, are deemed a threat to society and hunted by the rulers of the kingdom. The protagonist, Paedyn Gray, is an Ordinary surviving in the slums of Ilya, utilizing skills and observations taught by her deceased father to fake psychic abilities. However, after she inadvertently rescues Prince Kai- the future lethal Enforcer, or Ordinary hunter, of Ilya, she is thrust into the purging trials, a deadly, televised, tournament designed to showcase the power of the Elites.

The highlight of this book is the psychological tension and the layered character dynamics, especially with the twists near the end. Paedyn and Kai share a compelling banter that helps develop that slow burn romance for the readers, which Roberts does a phenomenal job of conveying. She keeps the high stakes tangible, especially since Kai’s literal duty is to execute people of Paedyn’s status, or “kind”, as they are called in the book, making it clear that they are viewed as a completely different species or creature in their eyes. 

My only critique is that it drags a bit in the middle. Once the trials begin, the plot stalls in a repetitive cycle of training montages and circular inner monologues rather than advancing the trial’s actual stakes. Additionally, the similar structures to other dystopian classics such as The Hunger Games and Red Queen are hard to ignore, making the middle chapters somewhat predictable. 

Regardless of those pacing issues, the high-stakes payoff makes it a great read that easily earned 4 stars. I highly recommend Powerless to teens who appreciate a dark romantic fantasy, high-stakes political rivalries, and witty dialogue. Because it’s the first of a trilogy, it’s absolutely necessary to read this book.

Why Fish Don't Exist by Lulu Miller

Book: Why Fish Don't Exist by Lulu Miller

Rating: 5 Stars 

Review Writer: Phoebe G.

Why Fish Don’t Exist follows Lulu Miller as she recounts the biography of famed fish taxonomist David Starr Jordan interspersing segments of her own life’s story. Miller attempts to find meaning and order in the world through the life of David Starr Jordan, potentially leaning more than she would have originally liked. 

 

My favorite part of the book was definitely how well the story kept me invested in the characters and what was going to happen next. I never fully knew what the next big plot point would be. I also thought the shorter length was nice so that I could read this book as a quick break from the other things I was reading. 

 

I think the only part I didn’t like was the change from the plot of the novel to a description of the taxonomy of fish towards the end of the book. The change didn't feel too abrupt, however, I had wished there had been a larger focus on the taxonomy interspersed with the plot. 

I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who likes non-fiction, anyone who enjoys a fast paced plot, and anyone looking to read about the obsessive nature of humans. 

Overall I would rate it 5 stars.

The House in the Cerulean Sea by TJ Klune

Book: The House in the Cerulean Sea by TJ Klune

Rating: 4.5 Stars 

Review Writer: Phoebe G.

The House in the Cerulean Sea follows Linus, a caseworker for the Department in Charge of Magical Youth as he learns about the value of family and individuality despite prejudice. It is a slow paced, slice-of-life fantasy novel focused on the connection between Linus, the magical children he meets, and the adults in charge of the orphanage Linus is staying at. This is also the first book in a two book series although the second novel doesn’t follow the same characters.

I liked how well developed even the most minor characters were and how realistic the plot of the story felt. Every character’s reactions and emotions within the story make sense and feel unique to them.

I think the ending felt a little rushed and could have used more time to develop. I also felt that the big plot twist wasn’t as surprising as it could have been, however, that didn’t make the story any less enjoyable.

I would recommend this book to readers who like Douglass Adams as the writing style and humor feels similar. I would also recommend this book to anyone who enjoys slice-of-life style stories.

Overall I would rate it 4.5 stars.

Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte

Book: Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte

Rating: 4 Stars 

Review Writer: Phoebe G.

Wuthering Heights is a classic novel that explores the themes of violence, desire, and generational trends. It is the account of a man named Mr. Lockwood as he learns the history of his newly acquired house, Thrushcross Grange. Lockwood also learns of Wuthering Heights and meets his unpleasant neighbors Heathcliff, Cathy, and Hareton. After only one night stuck at his neighbor’s house Lockwood sees a ghostly figure and is quickly sent home. 
 
I really liked how Wuthering Heights showed the many ways and reasons why people can become cruel. It was written with large amounts of visual imagery that set the book beautifully in the English moors, however, the descriptions of violence were written bluntly. This helped make the violent acts seem commonplace yet separate from the character’s lives on the moor. 
 
I found the language a little challenging to grasp at times due partially to the age and also because of how dense it was but it was always possible to understand if I spent time on it. I also found most of the main characters fairly unlikable but their worse qualities also helped add to the story and how well it was able to explore its themes. 
 
I think the target readers for this book are definitely people who want to read classics, people who want to explore themes of violence without excess gore, and more mature readers. 
 
Overall I would rate it 4 stars.

Babylonia by Constanza Casati

Book: Babylonia by Costanza Casati

Rating: 4.8 Stars 

Review Writer: Anika A.

Set in the 9th century, Babylonia is a gripping tale of love and war, hatred and friendship, and the struggle for power in the pursuit of a better life.

Semiramis, an orphan adopted by a village shepherd, grows up alongside his gentle and caring son, Amon. While Amon offers her comfort, their father is cruel and abusive, often finding excuses to beat her. Despite the violence, Semiramis learns to endure and stand her ground, vital for her survival.

One day, while in the forest, she robs a man and gets chased. What follows is a series of escalating events that culminate in the man's death—who, as it turns out, is the governor of the village, Eber-Nari, where she lives. Soon afterwards, their empire Assyria loses its civil war and replacements are set in.

This is when Semiramis meets Onnes, who rescues her from her harsh life and brings her to the capital as his wife, offering her a chance at a new beginning.

The story is full of unexpected twists and turns, with bloody moments and hints of war that is probably best for older readers. If you enjoyed The Keepers of Imbria, The Song of Achilles, or The Lord of the Rings, you’ll likely find Babylonia as one of your new favorites.

I couldn’t put the book down once I got the first few chapters – I finished it quickly and would give it a solid 4.8/5

The Wren in the Holly Library by K.A. Linde

Book: The Wren in the Holly Library by K.A. Linde

Rating: 4.5 Stars 

Review Writer: Anika A.

The Wren in the Holly Library by K. A. Linde is a thrilling story that blends old Gaelic tales with modern characters and issues. 

In a world overrun by monsters  - goblins, vampires, druids, and more - human survival is a battle that many lose. Born in New York City, Kierse is raised by a criminal mastermind who teaches her not just how to survive, but to adapt and thrive - by stealing and outwitting others.

When a major heist in a mansion takes a turn, Kierse uncovers hidden talents that some call luck and the more intelligent call magic. This sets off a chain of events filled with danger, deception, and discovery within their worlds that will determine the next six months. It pulls you into a deep world, where you feel like you are navigating the issues along with the characters.

As the first book in The Oak and Holly Cycle duology, it is impossible to read one without feeling the urge to pick up the next. What I appreciated in the book included the writing style and the distinct ways that all the characters get introduced and flowed. The only thing I didn’t like was how the book packed so much action in the last few chapters and landed on a cliffhanger. I would rate it a 4.5/5.

This book is for people who like slightly dystopian and romantic books such as Fourth Wing, and books by Kerri Maniscalco or Leigh Bardugo.

Powerless by Lauren Roberts

Book: Powerless by Lauren Roberts

Rating: 4 Stars 

Review Writer: Ava P.

Powerless by Lauren Roberts is a gripping dystopian fantasy set in a world where power defines fate. Paedyn Gray, a ‘Powerless’ girl in a society ruled by the powerful Elites, hides her lack of abilities to survive. When she is thrust into the deadly Purging Trials, she must outwit lethal enemies and dangerous allies. With romance, secrets, and rebellion brewing, Paedyn’s fight for survival could change everything.

I really enjoyed the witty banter that was often used in exchanges between the two main characters, Paedyn and Kai. This made me laugh so many times while I was reading it, and really added a comedic element to the story.

On the other hand, I did not like how the author left readers on a massive cliffhanger at the end of the first book and I feel that she could have tidied the ending up just a little bit.

I would recommend this book to people who enjoy reading fantasy or enjoyed the book The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins as Powerless has a similar plot in terms of those game-like scenarios.

Overall, I rate this book a 4/5 stars.

Lightlark by Alex Aster

Book: Lightlark by Alex Aster

Rating: 3 Stars 

Review Writer: Ava P.

In Lightlark by Alex Aster, Isla Crown joins the Centennial, a deadly competition held once every hundred years, where rulers of cursed realms fight for survival and the chance to break their curses. Each realm hides secrets but Isla’s is the most dangerous and game-changing of them all. As alliances form and betrayals unfold, she must navigate lies, love, and sacrifice. With her realm’s fate on the line, Isla must decide who to trust—and who to destroy.

I really liked how well the author described the setting, it really made the book feel immersive and made me really imagine the setting in a clearer way. I felt transported to this mythical place.

I did not like how the book ended as it ended on a weird cliffhanger which I personally did not enjoy. I would have preferred more closure and definitive and clear ending.

I recommend this book to readers who enjoy reading fantasy but like huge plot twists that always keep you guessing.

Overall, I rate this book a 3/5 stars.

The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky

Book: The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky

Rating: 5 Stars 
Review Writer: Teodora B.

The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky is a novel told through a series of letters written by a shy and observant high school freshman named Charlie. From the very beginning, the book pulls readers into his inner world as he navigates friendships, love, and the overwhelming emotions that come with growing up.

Charlie isn’t like any typical main character—he’s quiet, thoughtful, and incredibly introspective. Through his eyes, we get to see the honest experiences of someone who feels like an outsider. What makes this book stand out is how it handles heavy topics such as mental health and grief, while also showing the importance of close friendships and relationships. Charlie’s friends, Sam and Patrick, help him break out of his shell and start to participate in life.

I really liked how real the writing felt. It’s simple, but powerful:  the depth of his words and emotions is what makes the story so memorable. Even though the book takes place in the early 90s, the feelings and struggles are still relatable and relevant to teens today. One thing to note is that the pacing is slower and more reflective, so if you're looking for a fast-paced plot, this might not be the book for you. But if you like character driven books that will really make you think, this is the right book for you.

I’d recommend The Perks of Being a Wallflower to any and every teenager. I strongly believe that it is a book everyone should read. Its  powerful messages about identity, friendship, and healing will resonate with every teen that reads it.

Caraval by Stephanie Garber

Book: Caraval by Stephanie Garber

Rating: 4 Stars 

Review Writer: Ava P.

Caraval by Stephanie Garber is a magical fantasy about Scarlett Dragna, who escapes her abusive father to attend the legendary Caraval—an immersive, magical performance where the audience participates. Invited by the mysterious Master Legend, Scarlett must solve a series of clues to find her missing sister, Tella. But in this world of illusion and secrets, nothing is as it seems. As danger blurs into reality, Scarlett must decide what’s real before it’s too late.

I enjoyed how the book always had me on the edge of my seat - in the world of Caraval anything could happen at any given moment and you just could really never know what was coming next. The only thing I didn’t like about this book what that there wasn’t much character development of Scarlett and I think the story could’ve been more intriguing with more background and depth on this central character. I would recommend this book to fantasy readers who want to read something new and exciting. Overall I rate this book a 4/5 stars.

The Inheritance Games by Jennifer Lynn Barnes

Book: The Inheritance Games by Jennifer Lynn Barnes

Rating: 5 Stars 
Review Writer: Ava P.

The Inheritance Games by Jennifer Lynn Barnes tells the story of Avery Grambs, an ordinary teen who suddenly inherits a fortune from a dead billionaire she’s never met. To claim the money, she must live in the Hawthorne mansion and compete in a series of mysterious challenges against the billionaire’s four grandsons. As secrets unravel and alliances shift, Avery must figure out why she was chosen, all while navigating a web of danger and deceit.

I really enjoyed the witty banter that Avery often engaged in, it made me laugh out loud while I was reading the book. Additionally, it always kept me guessing as it had many fun plot twists. The only thing I disliked about the book was that it didn’t dive in deep into Avery’s past as I feel that would have helped me better understand certain her background and character. I would recommend this book to readers who love solving mysteries and enjoy books with romance plots.

Rebel Witch by Kristen Ciccarelli

Book: Rebel Witch by Kristen Ciccarelli 

Rating: 4 Stars 

Review Writer: Vihaan J.

Rebel Witch: The Crimson Moth: Book 2 by Kristen Ciccarelli is a wild, heart-pounding sequel that picks up right where the first book left off, plunging you into a chaotic world where magic, betrayal, and forbidden love collide. In this book, Rune Winters is forced to make impossible choices as she finds herself on the run, caught between survival and the guy she once loved, Gideon Sharpe, who is now torn between his duty and his undeniable feelings for her. The tension between them is electric, and their enemies-to-lovers dynamic is as captivating as ever. I loved how the book blended fast-paced action with romance—each chapter left you wanting more. The dialogue feels real, and the characters are so relatable, even when the plot gets a bit predictable or rushed in parts. While I wish there was a deeper dive into the emotional fallout of their choices, the overall ride is intense and addictive. If you’re into epic fantasy worlds with high stakes and complicated relationships that keep you guessing, this book is worth checking out.

Onyx Storm by Rebecca Yarros

Book: Onyx Storm by Rebecca Yarros 

Rating: 3.5 Stars 

Review Writer: Vihaan J.

Onyx Storm by Rebecca Yarros is a wild, adrenaline-fueled adventure that grabs you from the first page and never lets go. The novel puts you into a high-stakes world where intense romance meets explosive action, capturing the emotions of young love and personal struggle. Yarros does an impressive job of balancing heart-pounding fight scenes with quiet, introspective moments, making the story feel both epic and personal. I found myself rooting for the characters as they tackled challenges that felt all too real, despite the over-the-top drama at times. Although some plot twists seemed predictable and a few sequences felt a bit rushed, the overall experience remains captivating. This book is perfect for anyone who enjoys a blend of passionate romance, high-octane action, and emotional depth. It’s a rollercoaster of feelings that will leave you breathless. The book’s unique blend of adrenaline and emotion makes it stand out as a thrilling must-read for readers seeking adventure

The Eights by Joanna Miller

Book: The Eights by Joanna Miller 

Rating: 3.8 Stars 

Review Writer: Vihaan J. 

The Eights by Joanna Miller is a historical fiction novel set in 1920 at Oxford University, following four young women—Beatrice, Dora, Marianne, and Otto—who are among the first females admitted to the university. Each character brings a unique background and personal struggles, from dealing with the aftermath of World War I to confronting societal expectations. Their journey through academic challenges and forging deep friendships highlights resilience and empowerment themes. Miller's research and colorful storytelling accurately depict the era, showing readers the post-war atmosphere and the fight for gender equality. The novel's strengths are its character development and the portrayal of the women's achievements as they navigate a traditionally male-dominated institution. While the narrative is engaging, some readers might find the pacing slow at times and certain plot developments predictable. Nonetheless, The Eights is a compelling read that will resonate with fans of historical fiction and stories centered on female friendship and perseverance

Gryphon's Valor by Mercedes Lackey and Larry Dixon (Kelvren's Saga, Book 2)

Book: Gryphon's Valor by Mercedes Lackey and Larry Dixon

Rating: 4 stars 

Review Writer: Vihaan J

Gryphon's Valor is an exciting adventure set in the world of Valdemar. The story follows Kelvren, a courageous gryphon hero who’s back for more action after a near-fatal self-sacrifice that won him both respect and unexpected complications. As the second book in the Kelvren's Saga trilogy, it dives deep into the challenges of loyalty, duty, and the heavy cost of heroism.. What I really loved about this book was how real and relatable the characters felt, despite the fantastical setting. The dialogue was snappy and engaging, and I appreciated how the narrative balanced intense action with reflective moments. That said, there were a few things that didn’t quite hit the mark for me. Some parts of the plot leaned on familiar fantasy clichés, and the ending felt a bit too much like a cliffhanger. Overall, I’d recommend Gryphon's Valor to any teen who loves a good mix of fantasy adventure and character-driven storytelling. If you like epic journeys, intricate world-building, and series that keep you guessing, this book is definitely worth a read.

One of Us is Lying by Karen M. McManus

 
Title: One of Us is Lying by Karen M. McManus
Rating: 4 stars
Review Writer: Teodora B.

 

One of Us is Lying by Karen M. McManus follows an intriguing plot that will hook readers in instantly. 5 students walk into detention. 4 leave. Who murdered the 5th? 

 

Each student - Bronwyn, the brain; Addy, the beauty; Nate, the bad boy; Cooper, the athlete - has their own story, and fair share of secrets. But most importantly, they all have their own reasons for wanting Simon, the school’s most notorious gossip blogger, gone. When he dies under suspicious circumstances, they all become suspects. As the investigation unfolds, tensions rise, friendships are tested, and the truth becomes harder to hide. 

 

I really enjoyed this book, because the characters are all relatable. There’s such diversity in their backgrounds and personalities, that everyone can find a character they connect to. I also like how each chapter is written from a different character’s perspective. It really allows you to understand where they are each coming from, and their reasons for doing certain things or behaving a certain way. It also has a very unexpected ending, so if you usually instantly guess who did it, this will be much harder for you to figure out. However, one thing I wasn’t a huge fan of was the pacing. The book has a slower pace as compared to other murder mystery books. Some of the scenes seem unnecessary, as they do not contribute to the plot. Overall, I would recommend One Of Us is Lying to fans of murder mystery novels, and thrillers. 

 

The Prison Healer by Lynette Noni

 

Title: The Prison Healer by Lynette Noni
Rating: 5 stars
Review Writer: Ava P.

The Prison Healer by Lynette Noni follows Kiva, a skilled healer locked away in the dangerous prison in Zalindov. When the Rebel Leader arrives and is near death, Kiva is forced to treat her or face execution. Knowing that the Rebel Leader will not survive the trials set before her, Kiva volunteers to face the deadly trials in her place.  While fighting to survive, she uncovers dangerous truths about the prison and her own past. In a world where survival is a constant struggle, Kiva must make impossible choices to save herself—and perhaps everyone else. 

I really enjoyed how there were so many plot twists and mysteries which have the reader at the edge of their seat throughout the book.  It was a page turner! The only thing I disliked about the book was that it was in third person which didn’t allow me to really connect with the main character. I would recommend this book to readers who enjoy fantasy but also like reading mystery. Overall, I rate this book 5/5 stars.

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber

Title: Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber
Rating: 4 stars
Review Writer: Ava P.

Heartbroken Evangeline Fox makes a desperate deal with the mysterious Prince of Hearts, Jacks, to stop her true love from marrying another. The bargain leads her into a world of magic, dangerous curses, and tangled secrets. As she journeys through enchanted realms, Evangeline must outwit cursed princes, face treacherous enemies, and confront her own heart’s desires. Along the way, she discovers that the price of her wishes may be more than she ever imagined.
 
I enjoyed how the author creates such an unusual world with so many intricate and intriguing characters who are unlike any that I have read about before. I really liked that the storyline is so unique and really fun and light-hearted. The only thing I disliked about the book was that it had a slower start which made it harder for me to get pulled into in the beginning.
 
I would recommend this book to readers who are looking for a fantasy that is light-hearted and adventure-filled with strong and unique characters. Overall I rate this book a 4/5 stars.